If your bath towel stinks, and you're not even close to it, does that mean it's time to get a new one? I mean, um, hypothetically speaking.
Of course, this question has all sorts of nasty little philosophical buggers in it, some of which we've been discussing in one of my classes. What does it mean for something to stink when I'm not smelling it? Can something stink while not being smelled? We usually think that it would smell bad even if we weren't around to smell it. But how would we know that it was stinky? We couldn't unless we were smelling it. For something to be stinky is for it to be smelled (and determined as stinky). Does this mean that smelling it (as stinky)
makes it stinky? Interesting.
We have before us (at least) two choices concerning a property of a thing, sense experience of that property, and the relationship between them.
- The bath towel's property of being stinky causes the sense experience of smelling it (as stinky).
- Smelling the bath towel (as stinky) causes the bath towel to have the property of being stinky.
Hmm. (1) seems to be the most common sensical. But (2) isn't quite worded correctly, because we weren't concerned with the sense perception
causing the property of the towel but rather with the sense perception
being the reason for attributing the property to the towel. Without the sense perception, we wouldn't know that the towel was stinky, but the towel could have the property of being stinky without someone's smelling it. Epistemologically speaking (that is, regarding one's knowledge of the bath towel's properties) the sense perception is prior to the property possessed by the bath towel; this is because we wouldn't
know that it had the property until we smelled it. Metaphysically speaking (that is, regarding what the bath towel is in itself), the property is prior to the sense perception; this is because we wouldn't
receive a sense perception unless it had that property. Although this epistemological-metaphysical distinction might make sense, does it make sense to say that a property which is perceived by the senses can exist when unperceived?
Can't you tell that I have papers that need grading? That this is procrastination, not heartfelt philosophical monologue? That I need to go outside my apartment for the first time today?